patching...
Breaking: Obama and Christie to Visit Jersey Shore on Tuesday »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

LETTER: A Fleecing in Barnegat

Barnegat has collected almost $2 million for open space

 

This letter was written to the Patch by Barnegat taxpayer Jake Taylor.

Since December 2003, Barnegat Township has collected almost $2 million for the Barnegat Open Space Recreation and Farmland and Historic Preservation Trust Fund.

A penny has been added to every Barnegat residents' real property valuation for a total of $1,919,493.20, based on a referendum vote in 2001. There was an  assumption that these funds were to be used, according to the original ordinance introduced at the committee meeting in 2001: "of acquiring, developing or maintaining recreational or conservation of properties, acquiring or preserving historical properties," and "acquiring farmland for perservation or for payment." In reality, it appears this money has been used for everything but acquiring and preserving open space.

With the partial exception of the Girkin property, now called Meadowlands Park, not one cent of this money was apparently spent on purchasing open space. The Girkin property was partly paid with $800,000 from a Green Acres Grant and $400,000 from open space funds.

By attaching the PDF of the complete list of this reckless misappropriation of your tax dollars, I would like you, the taxpayer and owners of this fund, to see how you have been duped into believing it is for your own good.

From 2009 to 2012, barges for July 4 and Pirates Day, totaling $28,5000 were charged to this fund, $5,171 have been used for salt for roads, $9,774 for bleachers, $997 for Barnegat banners, and $1,244 for landscaping of town hall. How does any of this correlate to the original ordinance that the committee approved, or the referendum that was approved?

In a letter to Thomas Neff, at the Division of Local Government Services, following a request by me to look into this matter, Township Administrator David Breeden answered, "The open space funding could be utilized for the acquisition, developing, improvement, upkeep and maintentance of the following four items: 1. open space, 2. recreation, 3. historic preservation, and 4. farmland preservation," and goes on to cite a study, commissioned by the Township, that "Barnegat was deficient with regards to recreational related facilities." I fail to see how banners and barges address that deficiency.

Much of the open space funds were spent on improvements to already-owned football and softball fields on Lower Shore Road.

Some questions to contemplate: Why hasn't the interest from the money in trust appropriations been applied to the fund? Why has the entire Open Space Committee resigned?

I have spoken of this spending at many Township meetings and expressed my opinion on this matter.

I hope by letting you see for yourself this spending, controlled only by the five elected committee people and needing no authorization except their approval, you can form an opinion on this matter, and as in the past, let your voices be heard.

We currently stand among the highest tax rates in Ocean County and this type of spending is a large reason why. We must all work together to cut waste and see to it funds are used for the original intent - to purchase open space.

I hope this information is helpful to all and your concern reaches the hands that control our tax dollars.

Related Topics: Barnegat Township news

Howard Effron

6:12 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Great letter Jake. I figured I would add the pics of Lower Shore Road to let the residents of Barnegat see where this committee decided to invest hundreds of thousands of our "open space" tax money. Also barges, 911 memorials, payments to Birdsall, totally amazing.

Reply

Mac

6:57 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

The citizens of Ocean County, including Barnegat, have been very responsible in contributing their fair share in providing extra funds for the improvements of their neighborhoods and community lifestyles, regardless of the annual tax increases they experience. Now, if we could just identify candidates from within our own overwhelming group of responsible citizens that are more concerned about the neighborhood than themselves, we might improve our chances of getting a return on our well-intended investments.

Reply

WhiskeyTangoFoxtrot

8:38 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Thanks for the information Jake. Would love to see Colleen or someone else at The Patch actually write about this and interview our elected and non-elected officials and press them for something other than their canned answers.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Mac

10:18 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Hey Whiskey, it's kind of tough to be a fulltime editor and investigative reporter at the same time. They are two different positions that can often be at odds with one another. I agree that it wouldn't hurt if the integrity of this spending issue had a brighter light being shined on it though. Perhaps you, or someone else that either agrees or disagrees with you, could start an issue-related blog, ask questions of people involved directly and indirectly, and write about the responses and information they gather. I know such a blog would capture my interest.

Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Colleen Platt

10:44 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Hello Whiskey and Mac,
Just a few points of clarification. 1. I invited Jake Taylor to write this letter to the Patch - because he and I have known each other for about 12 years and I knew that he could review an issue like this in the comprehensive way he has here. 2. I have been covering this issue (please see the hyperlink above), and will continue to in the weeks and months ahead. 3. Mac, your idea is a great one. Anyone interested in blogging on this or other matters are encouraged to contact me at colleen.platt@patch.com.

Howard Effron

8:38 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Check this out. The same exact thing is happening in Moorestown, NJ. Here is the link to the Patch article: http://moorestown.patch.com/articles/council-approves-1-5-million-from-open-space-fund-for-fields.
I am under the same impression as the lawyer in Moorestown who will represent the people who oppose the use of open space funds for artificial turf and other mis-uses. I believe that open space funds can only be used first to "acquire" land, and than can be used to improve such land. But I'm no lawyer, keep an eye on this story from Moorestown to see how this plays out in court, if it gets that far.

Reply

Mike Howard

8:38 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Thanks Jake for standing up for the Barnegat Taxpayer.I have a few questions that maybe the members of the Committee or the administator can answer. Why should the following come out of Open Space money? With all the blue collar people working for the Town why did we pay outside landscapers $11,650.00 to trim trees around Townhall? Why did we use $28,000.00 to landscape around Townhall, them pay $1244.00 to maintain that same landscaping? Then $2800.00 out of Open Space money to remove trees from around the Cox House and from the Gazebo Park? We have a very nice 9/11 Memorial at the High School yet the Committee is building another one and using $2150.00 out of the Open Space fund for a bronze memorial. WHY? And the beat or should I say, the waste goes on. Some numbers seem to show that approx. $650,000.00 has been used so far at the Lower Shore Field. By the way, they are not done. Go take a look for yourself. When the mayor was asked if any Taxpayer money used for the fields, he became angry and yell, that no Taxpayer money was used. Funny thing is, Taxpayer money was used along with open space money. I'm not saying it, the Administrator said it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Larry Cataldo

6:44 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

GREAT LETTER JAKE, THX FOR BRINGING THESE THINGS TO THE LIGHT OF DAY, UNFORTUNELY MANY PEOPLE IN THIS TOWN JUST PLAIN DON'T CARE! THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON FOR YEARS,,,BUT THE TWP OF WEST BARNEGAT THINK THESE GUYS ARE THE GREATEST THING SINCE SLICED BREAD, SHAME, HOW UNINFORMED,,,,,

FGC92210

10:18 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Great letter Jake.
What do you suggest we, as resident, should do ?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Howard Effron

1:22 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

What needs to be done is this. And this solution is all about democracy, the constitution, the will of the people and the American way. The wording of the Barnegat Open Space Tax ordinance as it sits now, needs to be changed. The residents of Barnegat who oppose the way that our committee is using the Open Space Tax money need to come together, sign a petition an get a referendum question on next years Nov 2013 ballot. It is the only way that you will stop the spending. We as people have to play thier (the politicians) game. The committee knows darn well that the people of Barnegat overwhelmingly voted down a recreation tax. So they more or less laughed at us and spent the money anyway because of some loophole. Short of going to court as they are in Moorestown and spending more taxpayer money to fight, just get the Open Space Ordinance reworded. Everyone can argue back and forth, but that's what politicians depend on, turmoil. Until its done on a ballot voted on by the people, the politicians will never listen. One more thing, we all know that the whole committee reads these words and I would invite any one of them (including Elaine Taylor and Susan Conway) to respond.

Capt Jacobsen Mey

10:18 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Honestly, the State should be notified. A forensic financial audit needs to tske place as to investigate EXACTLY how certain funds are being used.

Services in this town have NOT improved. There is NO big business in Barnegat. There is NO need for any more housing - be it standard residential developments, Section 8 or Senior residences. We DON'T need any more "mini-strip stores" (such as the atrocity that is taking place next to the Delta gas on Bay Ave.

Has ANYONE from the Mayors Office even driven around Barnegat to view the multiple homes up for sale, the multiple overgrown properties of which homeowners cease to take care of (and are not fined based on Twp. Ordinances), have they seen the multiple ABANDONED homes that are most likely in foreclosure - and on and on and on.

Barnegat Tax Payers NEED to TAKE BACK BARNEGAT and vote OUT the incompetency.

How does the Mayor explain the now (5) brand new Police Explorers - again, of which another Patch article stated Barnegat only had enough money to UPDATE existing vehicles with new technology and only enough money to purchase (2) new vehicles. Gotta wonder, if the Open Space Funds is being misused, what other funds are being pilfered.

How much more money will us tax payers need to shell out for non-essential and misuse of funds?

If what is being said is NOT true - TWP should be transparent and show the public the expense records. Birdsall - funny how they end up with all the job bids isn't it...

Reply

Katie B

10:45 am on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

When I moved to Barnegat ten years ago from the South, knowing nothing about the town- it was impressed upon me that this was a town that deeply cared about preserving the green space. I have seen no evidence of that and as trees continue to come down in nauseating masses, the only impression Barnegat has left on me is that they care about making money. Shame on you, Barnegat Township officials, for being deplorable stewards of the environment.

Reply

Susan Conway

1:53 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Excellent letter Jake! As a candidate for Barnegat Township Committee this upcoming election, I can tell you that it has been incredibly disheartening to see the destruction of forests in favor of developers who also happen to be major contributors to the Ocean County Republican Party. Indeed, we the citizens of Barnegat have lost control, because the Committee has given that control to said developers. It certainly appears that the agenda of certain members of the Committee has gone far afield. The intent of the Open Space Fund, at least as to how it was explained to us, has gone far afield - from utilizing the funds for unrelated purposes to using it for questionably appropriate purposes but completely mishandling the purpose to the point that the effort is totally botched and completely overbudget. And of course, none of this helps the citizens of Barnegat with regards to the excessively large property taxes we all must endure. Somehow, Barnegat became a North Jersey town with North Jersey property rates . . . too bad nobody warned us!

I hear Jake, and Frank, and Mike, and all the citizens of Barnegat that have approached me during my campaign. The members of the Barnegat Committee who have held their seats for excessively long periods of time are up for re-election. Let's stop this tide of waste and vote Conway and Taylor for Barnegat Committee this November 6th!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Howard Effron

3:17 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Thanks for the response Susan, I'm sure that the people of Barnegat will keep all of this in mind when they go to the polls. Sorry you won't get to debate your opponents in a public forum, I believe that this issue is a large reason why they won't debate you. This whole Lower Shore Road deal has turned into a huge mess and money pit. Do you agree that we should get the wording changed by referendum so that there will be no doubt in peoples mind that their Open Space Tax money is going to exactly that. "Acquiring" and preserving open space, preferably to prevent future residential development that in turn will help all of Barnegat by easing the burden on the taxpayer. If you got elected, how would you handle this mess.

it could be me

3:34 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Great Letter Jake, Sometimes the truth hurts . I am all for the open space tax as long as it is being used for open spaces. I also have no problem build a field or two for youth recreation. However saying that, I cant so of the other things that have come out of this fund. First and formost--------everyone should go dwn and look at the mess the township is calling the "Free Field".
I really think its time for all voters to send a stong message this Nov---------WE NEED A CHANGE---------We must stop this running train, before it crashes.

Reply

Rick

3:48 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Great letter Jake. Thanks for keeping us informed on how much all this free stuff is costing us.

Reply

What about Bob?

3:48 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Come on Effron get real. You did NOTHING when the whole baseball field thing went down. You DID NOT SAY A WORD in fear of the senior vote. You said that Democrats could not do anything and are the same as the Republicans. You said you did "NOTHING" to help the people of Barnegat during your melt down at last years debate. Susan Conway should distance herself from you, because she is what this town needs. Someone with guts to stand up to those in power. After you lost the Democratic primary, Effron, you could not stop praising the Republicans enough, now you crawl out at election time again like a bad nightmare to Barnegat. By the way Susan was not responding to you, although your ego may have thought that she did.

Reply

Susan Conway

4:09 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Howard, it is very disappointing that the incumbents will not engage in the league of voters debate . . . a debate that is a long-standing tradition in Barnegat and run in a very fair and impartial way. They have failed to advise why they are refusing to debate. Some say because they believe they already have this election "sealed up" and some say its because they are afraid. I believe, as you do, that it would simply be too hard to explain Open Space and Lower Shore Road away and that culpability would have to be taken. Either way, it is the citizens of Barnegat that suffer yet again, because they will not be afforded the opportunity to observe, listen, and come to their own conclusions regarding the candidates. Instead, they must chase separate and distinct Meet the Candidates' gatherings. If elected, I would ensure first and foremost that a clear and legally accurate use for the current Open Space funds was established that would bind the committee. Once that was accomplished, all projects falling outside of proper use would be stopped or funded by other means if the project in question required its continuance. After that, a study would be conducted as to the need to continue to place taxpayer funds into Open Space. If the need was no longer present, those taxes would be eliminated. If a need was still present, then the question would be how much would be needed going forward.

Please visit Barnegat First on Facebook for more on Conway and Taylor for Barnegat!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Howard Effron

6:26 am on Thursday, September 27, 2012

Thanks for your response Susan. Well thought out and sensible. They only other way to end the misuse of these funds aside from a ballot question would be to vote out the people who have let this happen. Good Luck to you and Elaine.

God Bless America

4:27 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Good job Colleen. I have no idea why you would censor me for saying that the townships claim was "misleading" when the proof that you now publish makes it very clear what the open space money was spent on. I'm glad the truth came out. but the censorship and the closing of comments on this issue, I find very disturbing. Good job on getting the facts out to the people. Also, please take it easy with the many posts (losing Independent candidate) Effron. Barnegat does not need a repeat of what you did last year.

Good job Susan Conway, Barnegat could use you. Thanks again Colleen and God Bless.

Reply

nyr24fan

4:27 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Thanks Jake. When will we have any answer to Jake's questions and so many more. Like what are we doing with the Edwards school? Why do we allow the Cox House to fall apart if people value it so much and it is such a essential part of the community? Why did we purchase Medowedge Park if we have no use for it? Why are we spending money on Lower Shore for a field we didnt need? When the Class of '12 who just graduated Barnegat High School talk about Barnegat to thier new friends in college I wonder what they say their town in know for? Or what memories they have from thier town? Probably they pretend they are from Manahawkin.....

Reply

Diogenes

7:17 pm on Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Well said Jake. As you have noted, this problem has been in existence for a number of years and is justified by the administrator and township committee to satisfy the desires of a small group of vocal individuals who have the ear of the governing body and the administrator in particular. It is unfortunate that there appears to be no direct way to force an accounting of the expenditures from this fund. Please keep up the efforts. You have many supporters in this battle.

Reply

Capt Jacobsen Mey

6:26 am on Thursday, September 27, 2012

It's as easy as contacting this agency, as there is no favoritism or political influence tolerated:

http://www.state.nj.us/sci/faq.shtm

Enjoy Barnegat Taxpayers!

Reply

Erric L Zdzchowski

10:58 am on Thursday, September 27, 2012

The people of Barnegat have consistently VOTED for this kind of behavior giving the incumbents a free run on the people that got them into office. Unfortunately, people want free crap and don't care from where it was paid or by whom. The politicians know they can wave some petty give-a-way or shiny lightshow in front of everyone which will make them forget this type of CRIME come election day. Wake Up Barnegat!

Reply

Ray

10:58 am on Thursday, September 27, 2012

I commented in the past that the artificial turf field would be a boondoggle. It is coming to past. They kicked Jake off the open space committee because he tells the truth. We have 2 Committee Men who work for Van Dyck. Who do you think their loyalties are for. Billie voted to approve a strip mall at W. Bay Ave. and Sandpiper Rd against the wished of residents of Heritage Bay. He has to run next year and we won't forget,

Reply

What about Bob?

7:56 am on Saturday, October 13, 2012

On 2/7/12 on the Barnegat Patch Effron said "When the Democrats in Barnegat retain a majority on the board, I don't think that you will see much change except for our paid professionals, but we will see. Voters don't turn out because they have no other choice. I'm looking for change, Murray Sabrin and Ron Paul, now that is the change that I'm looking for, what do you have to lose."

What do you think Susan Conway? Effron said you will change nothing, but who gets paid. Are you going to be riding the Ron Paul coat tails with the other Barnegat Democrats to victory? If you have Effron backing you, good luck to you and Ron Paul, you will need it.

Reply

Neener

1:05 pm on Thursday, September 27, 2012

Thank you so much for this letter. I am very concerned about the amount of developing going on.

I was reading recently of some concerned citizens going to a town meeting about this. The current elect told them if land is privately owned, they can't stop them from developing. Then the answer is to buy our last remaining open spaces. So...why isn't that happening???

We live in a VERY sensitive ecological area, it must be protected. Besides, I do not want to live in a concrete strip mall. Our natural beauty which we all love so dearly here, is slipping away.

Please remember this when you vote. And always keep informed of what is going on around us. "Question everything."

Reply

Rick

5:56 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012

I just added a few more pictures of the artificial turf at the 'field of dreams'.

Reply

Diogenes

10:26 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012

This is approaching the biggest waste of money that Barnegat has ever invested in. It is a shame that there appears to be no oversight in the money poured into this sink hole. It would appear that we have a bunch of amateurs playing at construction with no end in sight.

Reply

Leave a comment